Reviews
Beautiful shoes
"In order the black ones in Monday, June 1and had them by June 3rd. Thank you to all of you who said these run small. I normally wear a size 6. 5 across the board in all shoes however due to previous reviews I ordered a whole size up 7. 5 and they fit perfectly. I still like to use my leather stretcher to break them in which is what I will do with these shoes as well. Definitely order an entire size up. Beautiful shoes."
— Sophia (5/5)
TINY
"I was excited about this shoe. It reminded me of Inglorious Basterds when he made her pull her shoe out of his bag. . . BEAUTIFUL shoe. BUT - this shoe is tiny. I ordered a 7 1/2 - with another shoe boot in the picture and it is TINY - maybe a 6 1/2. Worse yet . . . I would take an exchange in any color but I was told they would NOT hold it for me. I was on vacation and could not return immediately. I love the boot in this picture. . . but bummed about the doll shoe."
— Robin (3/5)
Larger replacement is perfect
"I wrote a previous review that I was disappointed because the show was tiny - too small. Today, I received the replacement. IT IS BEAUTIFUL - A VERY SPECIAL SHOE! I did buy a full size larger than I normally wear - and it is snug. . . so order a full size bigger. GREAT LOOKING SHOE!"
— Robin B. (5/5)
So nice, bought twice
"While I have 9 other Bed Stu shoes that compete for the “top shoe” spot in my closet, it was the pure fact that after walking my dogs two miles to the park, practicing pitching on unstable grass/ground and then the walk back in the heels, I realized I just did all the things, comfortably, I would have done in sneakers like a normal human- so I immediately bought the other color. Tip: size up-I wear 7 in my bed Stu as a general rule, size 6 in other brands like MK, BCBG etc- but these are perfection at a 7"
— Mandee C. (5/5)
So right, but so, so wrong.
"So right, but so, so wrong. Such a cute shoe. I wanted these to work soooooo badly, but they got the ergonomics really wrong on this one. I have 5 pairs of BedStu and they are all comfortable. These ones though, the toe is so narrow, and goes in at such a sharp angle that noone with even remotely normal feet could wear them comfortably. I'm a size 8, and usually wear a size 8 1/2 in BedStu. I went up to a 9 in these and they are still so tight in the toes. I'm not sure that a 9 1/2 or 10 would even work. BedStu - I hope you will make these again with proper sizing. They would be a really hot seller, and a staple in so many closets. I added a couple of comparative pics with another pair of BS booties that fit great. They are an 8 1/2 btw. And yes, I understand that the mary janes have a higher heel. Please don't charge me, or anyone else a restocking fee on these shoes. The sizing is too far off to expect anyone to be able to predict the right size. Ladies - I know you want them, but the sizing is totally off, unless you have very narrow toes, or enjoy being in pain, leave these ones behind."
— SARAH B. (2/5)
"Love the look always love bedstu but the design on this one rubbed my heel when i tried it on and i knew it would never get better so I had to return"
— Jessica (4/5)
Grateful for honest description
"Love these MaryJane's, they are incredibly cute, and fit me perfectly. I am a 5. 5 and when I saw ""runs small"" in the description I bought them immediately. Boots I can always buy a 6, but when it comes to shoes it is so very hard to find my fit. I was turned on to Bedstu because of my small feet and have been a repeat customer ever since. I really appreciate when the company, and others who write reviews post if a shoe runs small. I would never purchase a Maryjane heel like these in a 6 without that information. They'd be too big and my heel would slip. I want to thank everyone so much for the perfect description. I also wouldn't mind if you made more 5. 5's I know Im not the only one out there LOVE the shoes."
— Laura C. (5/5)
"They are beautiful. Been looking at these for quite awhile and thankfully I ordered based on the reviews as to size. I absolutely love these."
— Jeanne (5/5)
I love bedstu but
"I love bedstu but these shoes did not fit, totally disappointed."
— Claudia B. (3/5)
Ishtar
"These shoes are so beautiful! I absolutely love the way they look. I first purchased my usual size 7 and they were way too tight. . so I exchanged for a 7. 5 thinking the half size would be just right. Unfortunately they are still so narrow at the toe and just hurt to wear☹️ I wish I would have been able to exchange again for an 8 but they only allow one exchange/ return per order. I may have to just sell these because they just hurt to wear and are too expensive to purchase another pair. . . love the look but unfortunately they are just too tight."
— Brandee R. (4/5)